Naila Kabeer on Why Randomized Controlled Trials need to include Human Agency

Naila Kabeer (Interviewed by Duncan Green)
Poverty to Power, 2019
Niveau: débutant
Perspective: Autre
Sujet: Relations Nord-Sud & développement, Réflexion sur l'économie
Format: podcast
Durée: 00:20:08

In this podcast, Nalia Kabeer talks about her work, criticising the way in which Randomized Control Trials (RCTs) is adopted as a sole form of impact assessment. At the beginning of the talk, she briefly describes The Ultra Poor Project (the context of her study), RCTs and its critiques (such as lack of acknowledgement of human agency, heterogeneity, and social context); also, the problem that most RCTs practitioners do not allow for qualitative research conducted in an integrated way as it might cause their studies “being contaminated.” In her research which her team conducted qualitative research independently within the RCT-conducted pilots, it finds that this methodological-individualistic quantitative foundation of this practice leads to some serious flaws that undermine its establishing causality and explanation. She concludes that to address the problem of poverty, the evaluation needs to provide information that explains their findings; the mixed methods of quantitative and qualitative studies are suggested.

Comment from our editors:

The talk is well organised such that the concept and critiques of Randomised Control Trials (RCTs), as well as her study, can be understood easily. It sheds light upon limitations of methodologies often employed by mainstream development economists/practitioners and adds contribution to the field by suggesting the way that might help to overcome this limitation.

Go to: Naila Kabeer on Why Randomized Controlled Trials need to include Human Agency

Nous soutenir

Ce projet est le fruit du travail des membres du réseau international pour le pluralisme en économie, dans la sphère germanophone (Netzwerk Plurale Ökonomik e.V.) et dans la sphère francophone (Rethinking Economics Switzerland / Rethinking Economics Belgium / PEPS-Économie France). Nous sommes fortement attachés à notre indépendance et à notre diversité et vos dons permettent de le rester !